Why
Christians are Leaving the Middle East
Christians Are Abandoning a Region They've Lived in for Two Millenniums
By Kristin Cjick, Christian Science Monitor
|

|
Iraqi
Christians attend a mass during Christmas Eve at Christ church in Amman December 24, 2009. |
Across the Middle East, where Christianity was born and its
followers once made up a sizable portion of the population, Christians are now tiny
minorities. Driven by different factors the search for better opportunities abroad,
their status as targets of Iraq's sectarian conflict, a low birth rate, and discrimination
the trend largely holds true across a region where Christians have maintained a
presence for two millenniums.
Where Are Christians Dwindling Most?
All around the region, Christians made up more than 20 percent of the population in the
early 20th century; today, they make up less than 10 percent. Iraq has seen perhaps the
most dramatic decline. Estimates of its Christian population at the time of the US-led
invasion in 2003 ranged from 800,000 to 1.4 million, roughly 5 percent of the population.
But targeted by killings, kidnappings, and threats, many fled in far higher
proportions than their Sunni and Shiite compatriots: an estimated 20 percent of Iraqi
refugees abroad are Christians. Only an estimated 500,000 to 600,000 remain.
Why Are Their Numbers Dropping?
Outside Iraq, which is a unique case, the most common motivator is economics, not
persecution. "People want to seek a better life, and that's relevant for all people
in the region, Muslims as well," says Fiona McCallum, a professor at Scotland's
University of St. Andrews who studies Christian communities in the Middle East. But
Christians in the region have traditionally been better positioned to emigrate than their
Muslim counterparts because of their higher education levels.
With a lower birth rate than Muslims, the Christian
population would decline even without emigration as Muslim births outpace Christian
births. And religious discrimination is also a factor. In Egypt, Coptic Christians say
they are subject to systemic government discrimination. And in the Palestinian
territories, Christians cite intimidation and land theft.
Is There More Tension With Muslims Now?
The level of sectarian strife in Iraq is certainly elevated. In Israel, relations between
Muslims and Christians are generally stable, says Dr. Una McGahern, who recently completed
her doctoral thesis on Palestinian Christians in Israel. "While there are elements
within both communities who would view the other in more hostile terms, there is a broader
consensus of unity and acceptance that exists and that builds on historic patterns of
coexistence in the region," she says. In some cases, she adds, the two communities
are brought together by perceived Israeli attempts to sow dissension.
Sectarian tensions have simmered in Egypt for decades, with
periodic eruptions. Earlier this month, Muslims killed six worshipers leaving mass and a
security guard allegedly in revenge for a Christian's rape of a Muslim girl.
Hilal Khashan, professor of political studies at the
American University in Beirut, says that tension has not increased, but that extra
attention is given to violence against Christians, both in Egypt and Iraq. "Acts of
violence that are driven by personal issues are frequent, but they only make the news when
they involve Muslims against Copts," he says.
In Syria, where Christians have fallen to 10 percent, there
are fewer tensions, however. President Bashar al-Assad, a member of a religious minority
himself, has an interest in keeping sectarian strife at bay, and his regime rigidly cracks
down on Islamic extremism. According to Dr. McCallum, many Syrian Christians feel they can
participate in state and society, though they complain of discrimination in conversion and
interreligious marriage.
Is the Rise of Political Islam a Factor?
In Egypt, where women once wore miniskirts on the street, most women are now veiled. It's
one of many signs of the growing role that Islam plays in Egyptians' lives, which can
leave Christians feeling uneasy. "You can't totally ignore that there has been a rise
in political Islam & and obviously if you're not part of that you will feel a bit
different," says McCallum. As Egypt's Christians watch the rise of Hamas in the
Palestinian territories or Hezbollah in Lebanon, many are increasingly worried about their
place in society.
What Effect Has the Exodus Had Regionally?
As Christians leave the Middle East, some worry they will leave behind an increasingly
polarized society. When members of different religions or sects live side by side, they
are more likely to see one another as people, rather than faceless adversaries, says
McCallum. The loss of the Christians in the Palestinian territories and Israel, says
McGahern, would be particularly tragic. "Diversity necessitates compromise and breeds
creativity," she says. "Without Palestinian Christians or Druze or Muslims, or
Jews for that matter, society would become more polarized and political options more
rigid." |