Winograd
member: Disturbing similarities between Gaza, Lebanon wars
Prof. Ruth Gabizon says that like war against Hizbullah in 2006, goals of recent
military offensive in Strip were unclear and it ended with 'insufficient ceasefire'
Vered Luvitch, Ynet News
"Israel has a tendency to belittle its enemies," said Prof. Ruth Gabizon, a
former member of the Winograd Committee, which probed the failures of the Second Lebanon
War in 2006.
Speaking at conference held by the Institute for National
Security Studies on Wednesday, Gabizon said "we like to call them (enemies)
terrorists; we look down on them and underestimate their legitimacy.
"We must understand that we are facing a stubborn
enemy that will not surrender easily. They are very serious as far as their sense of
righteousness is concerned," she said.
Gabizon claimed that part of the failure in Lebanon stemmed from the fact that the war's
goals were unclear, saying that the situation was similar to the one the IDF faced during
the recent offensive in Gaza.
The professor said that both wars ended with an "insufficient" ceasefire, adding
that "the conflict in Gaza is not over."
Retired Judge Eliyahu Winograd, who headed the Commission, told the conference that the
IDF's conduct during the operation in Gaza proved that it had drawn lessons from the war
in Lebanon, at least as far as its relationship with the media was concerned.
"There were no leaks by senior officers; the decision to prohibit soldiers from
bringing their cell phones to Gaza was implemented in full, and the policy of
accessibility to the press, which was supported by the previous chief of staff (Dan
Halutz) was abandoned," he said.
Winograd said the entrance of reporters into the battle zone in Gaza was carried out in
coordination with the army, adding that the IDF Spokesperson's Unit was the main source of
information for the media.
"It appears that the reporters and anchormen
internalized the lessons of the Second Lebanon War and did not compete with one another
for scoops," Winograd said. "The press cooperated with the Military
Censor." |