Lebanon democracy still
needs overhaul: analysts
by Joseph Badawi and Joelle BassoulBEIRUT, Lebanon -
Lebanon cleared its first democratic hurdle in the post-Syrian era with the weekend's
polls in Beirut but the one-sidedness of the contest and unpopular election rules mean the
voting system still needs work.
The elections in the capital, the first of a four-round process, saw a crushing victory
for supporters of Saad Hariri, which was however marred by a low turnout of fewer than
one-in-three voters.
Political analyst Ghassan Ezzeh said: "I do not think we can speak about free and
democratic elections because there was no real electoral battle."
But he said that "even if the new parliament will not have real popular
representation, world powers (the United States and France) have already given it
legitimacy, and this is enough."
Hariri's success is widely seen as a vote for his father whose February 14 assassination
in a Beirut bomb blast triggered a major political upheaval in Lebanon that led Damascus
to end its 29-year military presence.
As soon as Saad claimed victory late Sunday, he called for national reconciliation in a
country still bearing the scars of the 15-year civil war and extended an open hand to all
factions who helped the campaign that led to the Syrian pullout.
Independent observers and Interior Minister Hassan Sabaa attributed the low Beirut turnout
to the fact that Hariri's candidates were assured of victory and because some Christian
groups had called for a boycott due to electoral rows.
Even European Union observers hailed on Monday the "open and transparent"
conduct of the first round of elections and said there was "no big difference"
in the turnout from the last legislative polls in 2000 that stood at 33.8 percent.
Leading figures in the anti-Syrian opposition, which is expected to take the lion's share
of seats in the 128-member parliament, had called for a high turnout to give the new
government the maximum of legitimacy.
Turnout had been expected to be low because of the virtually guaranteed success of
Hariri's son Saad in the 19 seats up for grabs in Beirut. His ticket had already won nine
of the seats as its candidates stood unopposed.
Turnout was particularly low in Christian districts of the capital.
Former exiled Christian General Michel Aoun -- who recently fell out with Hariri and his
Muslim allies in the opposition -- and the powerful Armenian party Tashnag had called for
the boycott.
A senior Aoun aide, Alain Aoun, told AFP that "Beirut voters have expressed their
rejection of the electoral law which was drafted in the era of the Syrian
occupation."
Aoun's Free Patriotic Movement, which has however sponsored candidates in other districts,
considered that the electoral law prevented minorities from gaining true representation.
Hani Hammud, editor-in-chief of the Hariri-owned al-Mustaqbal daily, said "working
toward national unity after the elections would be achieved with the drafting of a new
electoral law to replace the current one which was drafted by the (Lebanese) authorities
and the services, under Syria's tutelage."
"The electoral law has rightfully frustrated many Lebanese, mainly the
Christians," he acknowledged.
"The first mission of Saad Hariri and his allies (in the opposition) will be to start
dialogue for a new electoral law, following a compromise with all parties," Hammud
said. |