Commentary
Road maps success could
return Lebanon to its former glory as Switzerland of the Levant
Parag KhannaContrary to all expectations, the war in Iraq made no dent in
Lebanese tourism in 2003. In fact, the number of visitors in 2003 jumped an estimated 5
percent over the previous year, due largely to Arab visitors concerned by both the
perceived anti-Arab sentiment elsewhere as well as the stark appreciation of the euro.
Fifty percent of visitors to Lebanon are non-Arab, however, and given the Lebanese
populations historical, even natural, cosmopolitan flair, it continues to present
opportunities for foreign tourism and foreign investment in the tourism sector which
could help spark a brighter, more stable future for the region as a whole.
For bewitched European Orientalists, Lebanon was once considered the Switzerland of the
Levant, and its capital, Beirut, the Paris of the Middle East. But in the late
1970s and early 1980s over a decade before world attention became fixed on the
destructive ethnic conflicts and civil wars of Bosnia, Rwanda and Afghanistan Lebanon
was devastated by one of the most complicated and multifarious sectarian conflicts of the
20th century, in which Israeli jets mercilessly pounded Beirut while Israeli and Syrian
client militias of Lebanons Christian, Sunni, Shiite and Druze factions besieged the
city, razing its monuments, factories, offices and homes. In all, there were almost
200,000 mostly civilian fatalities, with at least as many wounded. Consequently, a
walk through Beirut today is war tourism without the war.
The easiest way to get a sense of the unbearable lightness of being in Beirut during the
civil war is to rent the recent Hollywood action thriller Spy Games, starring Robert
Redford and Brad Pitt. Militia fighting on the streets of Beirut continued through the
1980s, with the government fading, even disappearing, into insignificance. Shelling and
sniper fire made crossing certain streets impossible, inspiring the Lebanese to bore
human-size holes through entire blocks of buildings to create mole-like passageways which
cut through bedrooms and living rooms. A Druze friend, whose family fled during the war,
once explained how Palestinians occupied Lebanese families homes and had to be
bribed, and often violently coerced, to move out. No authorities arbitrated such disputes,
leaving the Lebanese to persevere in their own Arab version of Miami. By frequenting fancy
social gatherings and upscale restaurants amid the crumbling, contested infrastructure,
the Lebanese acquired a reputation as world-class party-goers.
This legacy continues today on Monot Street, which is packed with as many bars and cafes
as one would expect in a Barcelona alley; or in the underground nightclub BO18, which with
its retractable roof is an easy contender for the worlds coolest disco. These
traditions of vibrancy and self-reliance were necessary to cope with the dysfunctional
side-effects of war, yet persist in the absence of strong authority. If they were to
impose rules, things would fall apart. Everything just works on its own, my friend
said with a shrug.
Even as Sunnis, Shiites, Maronites and Druze maintain dominant influence in their
traditional regional strongholds, they all share the breezy coast in cosmopolitan Beirut,
where on Sundays in the Muslim Hamra district, calls to prayer from tall minarets and
church bells compete in a religious cacophony. Instead of planning a memorial to
commemorate the civil wars victims or its conclusion, no effort is being spared to
erase all traces of the war. On the pedestrian Al-Maraad Street, the meeting point between
Hamra and the affluent Christian Achrafieh district, an outdoor exhibit tracks the
progress of the citys resurrection, which has advanced at a pace to rival that of
East Berlin. Photographs resembling Grozny are juxtaposed with images of Ottoman council
buildings restored to administrative glory, highlighting the mellow aesthetic of
neo-Islamic architecture. Another panel contrasts the national Sports City in 1982, when
it was decimated by Israeli warplanes, to its packed stands during the Asian and Pan-Arab
Games in the 1990s. Al-Maraad Street ends at the Place dEtoile, also known as Nijmeh
Square. Once barricaded with sandbags and gutted by bombs, it now serves as the pedestrian
hub of Beiruts Central District, with quaint, cafe-lined streets spinning off from
the Al-Abed clocktower.
Over millennia of foreign intermingling, Lebanese became the original globalization chic:
Their role throughout history as merchants and traders has always been strong. An Arab
saying recounts that books were written in Cairo, printed in Beirut, and read in
Baghdad. One cultural perk of being an imperial sandbox is that Syria and Lebanon
are the archaeological equivalent of icebergs, with perhaps 80 percent of their ancient
ruins still buried underground. In Beiruts Central District, the history of
Mediterranean civilization is excavated as simultaneous efforts to rebuild the shattered
city accelerate.
Geographically, Lebanon is but a mountainous sliver: its only a 90-minute drive from
the rough plains of western Syria to Beirut on the Mediterranean shore. Roughly
corresponding to the land of the ancient Phoenicians the name meaning red or purple
given to the Levantine people by the Greeks Lebanese history has indeed been a nonstop
succession of imperial occupations. Situated at the crossroads of civilizations,
Phoenicians from the port of Tyre founded Carthage in North Africa, but three centuries
later the city was invaded by the Babylonian king Nebuchadnezzar and then blockaded by
Alexander the Great. The Hellenistic period was quickly eclipsed by the Pax Romana under
Emperor Augustus, who brought great prosperity to Tyre and Sidon. Following the conversion
of the Lebanese to Christianity under Byzantine rule, Beirut grew to prominence, with its
law school the most famous throughout the Roman Empire. But a devastating earthquake and
tidal flood in 551 AD enabled a victorious Arab invasion, bringing both Islam and Arabic
to replace local dialects. The crusaders also took hold of the Levant in the 11th century,
but were ejected by the Mamluk sultans, who turned Tripoli, today Lebanons second
largest city, into a great center of Islamic architecture with the building of mosques,
madrassahs and hammams.
With Beirut as the Middle Easts most hip city, combining the elegance of Istanbul
with the seediness of Tangiers, Lebanon could become the next Turkey or Morocco on the
travelers map. In addition to its sandy beaches and archaeological treasures,
Lebanon also boasts the Middle Easts highest mountains, the three thousand meter
Lebanon range, which provides the only skiing in the Middle East. The Qadisha Valley in
the north offers convenient hiking terrain and rich forests of the Lebanese national
symbol, the cedar tree. Perched on a plateau below the forests is the village of Bcharreh,
where one can visit the home, now a museum, of Gibran Khalil Gibran, Lebanons most
famous writer, whose Prophet is one of the best-selling books of all time. Throughout the
country, luxury hotels provide all-season retreats for those seeking to beat the heat, get
out of the big city or experience multiple climates in a single day.
Driving south from Tyre, I passed through the town of Bint Jbeil, proudly identified by
its signage as the Capital of Liberation. The May 2000 Israeli withdrawal from
southern Lebanon was celebrated with great festivity nationwide. Hizbullah receives the
lions share of credit for Israels withdrawal. Cases of Katyusha rockets mark
many zones from which it frequently launched resistance, tellingly also just a few hundred
meters from the site of the Qana massacre. But Hizbullah seems to have changed with the
times. Recognizing that post-civil war Lebanon prefers pluralism to extreme sectarianism,
Hizbullah has had to combine its Shiite-driven agenda with a political platform, giving
itself plenty of attention via its own Al-Manar television station. It now focuses on
compensating, as during the civil war, for the lack of government provision of social
services. It therefore functions like Indias Shiv Sena in Bombay, building hospitals
and spending $3.5 million per year on educating even the most deprived Lebanese children.
Its stronghold of Baalbek once the ancient Greek city of Heliopolis remains
Lebanons second most visited city for its wonders of the ancient world, the ruins of
the 1st century AD Jupiter and Bacchus temples, which particularly at sunset exude their
aesthetic might over the neighboring fields.
If the road map does indeed advance, many Lebanese believe that peace with
Israel is possible. With their well-developed tourist infrastructure and cultural
adaptability, Lebanon and Israel are poised to gain the most from any progress on regional
peace as exotic destinations for pilgrims and sun worshippers alike. Another friend
believes this is just a matter of when, not if, saying: Lebanon is in its fabric
comfortable with European values. It can play an important cultural and economic role as a
moderate society.
Indeed, it is not madrassahs which have risen from the rubble of Beiruts civil war,
but French boutiques, and Mercedes-Benz far outnumber other automobiles. And this year,
the number of tourists passed the 1 million mark, representing steady growth with room to
improve as Lebanon continues to accelerate its national reconstruction effort.
Parag Khanna is senior research analyst in
Governance Studies at the Brookings Institution, and an adviser to the World Economic
Forum in Switzerland. He wrote this commentary for The Daily Star |