Time for Palestinian suicide belt-bombers
to desist
Abdeljabbar AdwanEven
long before Israel launched its recent invasion of Palestinian cities, towns, villages and
refugee camps, statistics gathered by world bodies showed that every Palestinian young man
had already endured severe hardships such as arrest, beatings and injury resulting
from an Israeli occupation that has lasted 35 years.
Older generations suffered even more. They had to contend with deportation, as Israel was
created at their expense. Now, the suffering is back with a vengeance, sparing no one its
devastating effects.
Add to this the feeling among almost all Palestinians, that the world has betrayed them in
favor of Israel, and it isnt hard to figure out why many Palestinians support
suicide bombings against Israelis nor indeed why they supported attacks against
civilian targets all around the world in the past.
Yet, despite the fact that the Palestinians are still suffering, circumstances dictate
that the phenomenon of suicide bombings and support for them must be brought to an
end.
The final goal of all Palestinian armed factions is the achievement of a balanced and just
peace through a settlement that realizes Palestinian collective and individual rights. All
actions taken by these factions must be looked upon from this viewpoint only. Getting
dragged into a game of tit-for-tat and an eye-for-an-eye will only result in a lot of
blind people.
When Palestinians recall Ariel Sharon and his terrorism, Benjamin Netanyahu, and the Likud
with its rejection of the very idea of a Palestinian state, they should not direct their
desire for revenge towards all Israelis and Jews. Palestinians should remember the peace
demonstration in Tel Aviv earlier this year, when more than 100,000 Israelis chanted for
peace and denounced war, occupation, settlement building and Israeli Army terrorism. For
such a large number of Israelis to adopt such a position under difficult circumstances
demonstrates exceptional bravery on their part.
These Israelis, it must be remembered, were the targets for Palestinian suicide bombers.
They were also targets for extreme right-wing propaganda, both in Israel and the United
States, which encourages feelings of vengeance, justifies state terrorism and accuses all
those who oppose it of betrayal. Yet more than 100,000 people chose to side with their own
humanity. This stance on its own is enough to stop all suicide attacks, lest these people
are harmed.
Before the peace demonstration in Tel Aviv (and before Israels latest invasions) a
large number of Israeli Army reserve officers decided publicly to refuse to serve in the
Occupied Territories. This movement grew to the point that when the invasion came, those
who refused to take part preserved their humanity, while those who served demonstrated an
appalling collapse of moral values, by stealing, looting and sadistically treating the
Palestinians.
It would be unfair to view these two groups of soldiers similarly, just as it would be to
consider Israeli soldiers who agree to serve in the Occupied Territories and the civilians
who oppose the occupation to be the same. This is another reason why resistance
should be restricted to the occupied Palestinian areas only, to be directed against
soldiers and Jewish settlers who are openly flaunting international law and UN
resolutions.
Sharons official policy of terrorism has been exposed before the entire world; the
only thing that can redeem Israels prime minister and his extremist government is
more Palestinian suicide attacks. These attacks will win Sharon sympathy on the world
stage as well as inside Israel, to the detriment of the Israeli peace movement. Any
suicide attack that takes place now will mean that there is an implicit understanding
between Palestinian Islamic fundamentalism and Israeli Jewish fundamentalism: both despise
the very idea of peace and wish to undermine any chance of a peaceful settlement.
That is why Arab and Palestinian support for suicide bombings must end. The fledgling
anti-occupation movement in Israel and around the world must be given a chance to spread
its wings and redress the balance in favor of an equitable peace, especially after both
sides to this conflict have seen the bitter suffering of war. This doesnt mean, of
course, that resistance to occupation must be stopped.
While it is true that Likuds recent vote against the idea of a Palestinian state
encourages radical action, since the party seems to have destroyed any chance of peace, it
has to be remembered that Likuds action was contrary to the wishes of more than half
the Israeli people, as well as against the policies of its Labor partner in the ruling
coalition. Suicide missions would cancel out these differences, and would unify the
Israeli home front behind the Likuds fundamentalist policies. By contrast,
restricting resistance activities to the Occupied Territories would have the opposite
effect under the circumstances, and would serve the cause of peace
and coexistence.
It is not only in Israel that a debate is going on about the goals of a political
settlement in the Middle East. In the United States, the role played by various lobbies
and interest groups formulating government policy is in full swing. The Likuds
vision of a settlement seems to be on a collision course with the American policy of a
Palestinian state living side by side with Israel a policy that has been enshrined in a
recent UN resolution.
It has become widely known that there exists in the US a fundamentalist Jewish-Christian
alliance in support of Israeli extremism in the Middle East. This alliance is the subject
of intense public debate. More suicide missions would act against the interests of the
Palestinian people, the avowed vision of the US government and peace-loving forces in
America, Israel and around the world. A suicide operation serves the benefit Likud and its
fundamentalist allies only.
Sharon deserves to be castigated as an extremist and a war criminal, but he will be forced
to use even more violent means if another suicide operation takes place, in order to
regain the support of the right-wingers that have gone to Netanyahus side. The
result will be more devastation visited on the Palestinian people, and more destruction of
the civilian infrastructure of Islamic Jihad, Hamas and the Palestinian Authority in Gaza.
The international community, meanwhile, will not be able to condemn Israel.
Netanyahu and his fundamentalist allies in Israel and the United States are eagerly
awaiting the next suicide bombing to vindicate their policies. That is why it is of the
utmost importance for those responsible for Palestinian suicide attacks against Israeli
civilians to stop them immediately, and concentrate instead on fighting against occupation
and settlement activity, while reserving the right to respond in kind to Israeli attacks
against Palestinian civilians. In other words, suicide attacks should be kept in reserve
as a strategic deterrent against Israeli attacks against Palestinian civilians, thus
keeping wide avenues open for interaction between Palestinians, Israelis, and Americans.
It is vitally important for those Palestinian factions that carry out suicide missions to
keep the interests of the Palestinian people foremost in their minds, and not be carried
away by the sermons of religious leaders who will not care about the fate of the
Palestinian people when the worst comes to the worst.
Resisting occupation is a legitimate activity, supported by UN resolutions and
international law. Even US policy is not against legitimate resistance, while more than
half the Israeli people oppose their countrys occupation of the West Bank and Gaza.
There is no justification now for getting carried away by emotions and vengeful instincts.
It is far better to escalate resistance within the framework of international law, while
giving the Israeli peace movement time to act.
Abdeljabbar Adwan, a Palestinian analyst, wrote this
commentary for The Daily Star
Copyright © The Daily Star |